reviews
Home > Buying Guides>

Film vs Digital - The Great Camera Debate

Film vs. Digital
Digital cameras take and store pictures entirely electronically, while film cameras record images onto light-sensitive film.

Traditional film technology Digital imaging technology
How does it work? Exposes a visual image onto special light-sensitive chemicals within the film.
The film itself contains a physical representation of the image.
Films are either Colour Negative (yielding prints) or Transparency (slides, which require a slide projector/viewer or to be scanned into a computer).
Films are available in various numbers of exposures usually 12, 24 or 36.
Creates a digital representation according to the colour and intensity of light falling upon an array of special digital receptors.
Images are digital files stored in digital memory. All but the least expensive digital cameras use removable memory cards that are available in various sizes (typically from 8MB to 128MB)
Some cameras allow you to choose whether to store more images of lower quality, or fewer images of higher quality. As a rule of thumb, 8 MegaBytes (MB) of storage will accommodate 16 high-res images or approximately 50 low-res images from a 2 Megapixel camera.
There are several different types of memory card—see our feature on Solid State Memory Cards.
What is the future of this technology? Film technology dates back almost 200 years, and is thus now mature and affordable.
APS system is a hybrid between traditional and digital photography technologies.
Mainstream uses of film likely to decline as digital cameras become increasingly affordable and impressive.
Based on still-evolving digital semiconductor technology, therefore performance should keep improving and costs will continue to decrease.
Is it easy for beginners to use? Yes: even affordable cameras have high-tech systems built-in to automate every aspect of camera operation, from loading the film, to taking the picture. Yes: just switch on, point and click, then upload pictures to your PC when desired, or transfer them on the solid-state memory card. PC software will be probably supplied with the camera to enable storage, indexing and simple editing of your images.
What are the options for more serious photography? Best choice of flexible, high performance products and systems for enthusiast and professional photographers, at the best prices. More expensive models now offer enthusiast facilities, such as full manual exposure and focussing, alongside full automation for high-quality ‘point and shoot’ photography. High-end digital cameras are still more expensive than their film-based equivalents.
Which format's pictures are the longest-lived and the easiest to share with friends and family? Once exposed, and if properly developed, transparency and negative films (and prints made from them) should last for decades. Prints are easiest to pass around and view with friends and family in person. Digital images exist only as digital data (in a camera's memory or PC's hard disk) and thus are not physically permanent, but in theory could last forever if properly stored.
It is often not convenient for a group of people to view pictures on a PC screen or a camera’s built-in LCD screen, but they are much easier to send by email.However users can make hard copies with a suitable PC inkjet printer and special photographic paper, or via the service of an online photo-finishing company.
Alternatively, unbeatable.co.uk now stocks dedicated photo printers that can link direct to some of the latest cameras and produce prints just like those from 35mm film.
And digital images can be easily 'backed up' like PC data, taking up much less space than stacks of photo prints or boxes of transparencies.
What about running costs? With a film camera, the principal running costs are their films and their developing costs. Occasionally you will need to replace the small batteries that run built-in flashguns, exposure automation and film winders. This becomes more of an issue with cameras including power zoom lenses and more complex electronics (e.g. in the most expensive SLRs). With a digital camera there are no film costs, but their all-electronic systems consume a lot of power. Battery costs soon mount up unless the camera includes a rechargeable option. Some cameras now use alkaline batteries alongside rechargeable, to extend operation. Also, don't forget the cost of producing prints from a digital camera whether via PC printer, dedicated photo printer or an online photofinishing service.


Unbeatable RSS Feeds
* *